- Screening at three of the following international film festivals (listed chronologically): Sundance, Berlin, True/False, SXSW, Full Frame, Tribeca, Hot Docs, Cannes, Silverdocs, Los Angeles, Toronto, Sheffield and IDFA.
- Screening at two of the above film festivals and winning a grand jury prize at one of them.
- Screening at two of the above film festivals and reporting at least $5,000 in North American theatrical box office.
- Reporting at least $20,000 in North American theatrical box office/li>
Filmmakers with films that meet the criteria should make sure the Cinema Eye organizers are aware of their film, and should request consideration. There is no entry fee.

